Nootra

Cutting a supplement brand's checkout drop-off in half

Strong paid traffic, people adding to cart and vanishing. A structured CRO programme — hypothesis, control, measured result — rather than a redesign.

What changed

  • −47%

    checkout abandonment, cart to payment step

  • 8

    hypotheses tested in eight weeks

Figures not yet substantiatedThe conditions behind these numbers — the measurement window, the traffic it covers, and what else changed — are being confirmed with the client. Until they are, treat the figures as indicative rather than verified.

The context

The brand was spending well on paid acquisition and pulling strong top-of-funnel traffic. But the numbers told a clear story: people were adding to cart and then vanishing. Store-wide conversion sat below where a brand with this traffic quality and order value should be.

The previous developer had treated the theme as “done.” Nothing was being measured. No tests were running. The team was guessing.

The problem

Three issues surfaced in the first session-recording review:

  • The cart drawer hid shipping cost until the final checkout step — buyers hit an unexpected number and bailed.
  • The mobile add-to-cart sat below a heavy block of marketing copy, so on the device most of the traffic used, the primary action was off-screen.
  • There was no reassurance at the decision point — no guarantee, no social proof near the buy box.

The intervention

I ran a structured CRO programme rather than a redesign. Each change was a hypothesis, instrumented and measured against a control:

  1. Surfaced shipping thresholds in the cart drawer with a free-shipping progress bar.
  2. Rebuilt the mobile product page so the buy box sits above the fold and the copy below it.
  3. Added a trust cluster at the buy box — guarantee, verified-review count, and a low-stock signal only where genuine.
  4. Simplified checkout to a single accelerated path for returning customers.

The process

Weekly cadence: review the data, ship the next test, read the result, decide. No test ran without a control and a pre-registered success metric. Losers were reverted without ceremony — roughly a third of hypotheses didn’t win, which is exactly how a real programme behaves.

The result

Checkout abandonment fell by nearly half over the eight weeks, and store-wide conversion moved up meaningfully. Because the gains came from existing traffic, the brand’s blended acquisition cost effectively dropped without touching ad spend.

A third of the tests lost. That is not a failure of the programme — it is the programme working.

Where to go next

This was their store. The free read tells you what’s happening on yours — send the URL and roughly how many sessions a month.

See where you’re losing it